| Statistic | Value | Details |
| Biggest win by Central Coast Mariners | 3 goals | 11/03/2023 Central Coast Mariners 4-1 Macarthur FC |
| Biggest win by Macarthur FC | 2 goals | 12/06/2021 Central Coast Mariners 0-2 Macarthur FC after extra time (Finals) |
| Most goals scored by Central Coast Mariners against Macarthur FC | 4 goals | 19/03/2022 Central Coast Mariners 4-2 Macarthur FC |
| 11/03/2023 Central Coast Mariners 4-1 Macarthur FC | ||
| Most goals scored by Macarthur FC against Central Coast Mariners | 3 goals | 10/02/2022 Central Coast Mariners 3-3 Macarthur FC |
| 13/11/2022 Central Coast Mariners 2-3 Macarthur FC | ||
| Red cards | James Meredith | 12/06/2021 Central Coast Mariners 0-2 Macarthur FC after extra time (Finals) |
| Brian Kaltak | 13/11/2022 Central Coast Mariners 2-3 Macarthur FC | |
| Hattricks scored in this fixture | None | N/A |
| Most goals scored in this fixture | 1. 3 goals | Daniel De Silva |
| Jason Cummings | ||
| 3. 2 goals | Marco Tulio | |
| Marco Urena | ||
| Matthew Hatch | ||
| Adrian Mariappa | ||
| Garang Kuol |
| Season | Date | Match Type | Central Coast Mariners wins | Draws | Macarthur FC wins |
| 2020/21 | 3/01/2021 | League | Macarthur FC 0-2 Central Coast Mariners | ||
| 2020/21 | 8/03/2021 | League | Central Coast Mariners 2-0 Macarthur FC | ||
| 2020/21 | 27/05/2021 | League | Macarthur FC 1-2 Central Coast Mariners | ||
| 2020/21 | 12/06/2021 | A-League Finals | Central Coast Mariners 0-2 Macarthur FC after extra time | ||
| 2021/22 | 5/12/2021 | League | Macarthur FC 1-0 Central Coast Mariners | ||
| 2021/22 | 10/02/2022 | League | Central Coast Mariners 3-3 Macarthur FC | ||
| 2021/22 | 19/03/2022 | League | Central Coast Mariners 4-2 Macarthur FC | ||
| 2022/23 | 13/11/2022 | League | Central Coast Mariners 2-3 Macarthur FC | ||
| 2022/23 | 13/01/2023 | League | Macarthur FC 1-2 Central Coast Mariners | ||
| 2022/23 | 11/03/2023 | League | Central Coast Mariners 4-1 Macarthur FC | ||
| 2023/24 | 29/10/2023 | League | Central Coast Mariners 1-2 Macarthur FC |